is reader supported. Our links may earn us a commission.

Learn More

Work Boots

Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boots – A Detailed Review

Summary Image
Workwear Logo
Rating : 7.7/10
Check Price on Amazon

Performance Breakdown


Bottom Line

Constructed with an iconic round toe design and a Vibram mini-lug outsole, the Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boot provides remarkable benefits long after the end of your workday.


  • Premium retro design
  • Relaxed fit
  • Strong construction
  • Versatile – for work and more relaxed settings


  • Outsole has medium to low traction
  • No safety toes or waterproof components


Full-grain leather

Type of Toe

Soft Toe


3.62lb / 1.64kg / 57.85oz



Shaft Size

6 inches


Vibram 430 Mini-Lug

Boot type



Red Wing

Safety certifications


Price range

$319.99 to 399.00


I had the chance to fully enjoy the Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boot with its versatile design that can be maximized in a variety of settings. This premium boot reminded me of motorcycle boots, with a rugged appeal that speaks of the durability coming from the premium construction and materials. This does not mean that the boot lacks grace, however, because it effortlessly maintains a stylishness that blends seamlessly with dressier clothes as much as it does with more laid-back outfit choices. I got the boot in black prairie leather that looked awesome with its dark color, which was further accentuated with the white stitching all throughout for a distinctive look. I appreciated the fact that the boot’s aesthetic appeal didn’t compromise its comfort features, as it delivered a relaxed fit that made it much easier for me to focus on the activities that I needed to do without worrying about irritation.


The Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boot is built with a robust construction that can keep up your activities without sacrificing comfort and aesthetics. It got its name from the footwear design that was originally utilized for working in blacksmith workshops and farms by daytime and easily transitioned to a more casual setting after work was done. The 6-inch structure provides superior ankle and foot protection from the elements so your foot can stay comfortable as you tackle the day’s most important activities. The premium leather upper offers long-lasting resilience against normal wear and tear while showcasing an impressive appearance that can be maximized within the workplace and elsewhere. This same material is used in the interior to provide all-day comfort as it follows the contours of the foot for a more personalized feeling. An oil-resistant Vibram outsole brings toughness to the boot’s structure and adds stability, but I find it lacking in the traction department, especially when walking on wet or slippery floors. The triple stitching all around the boot increases its durability so you can be sure that it can easily match your requirements when it comes to long-lasting performance. Below, we’ll take a closer look at the boot’s most notable attributes to see where it delivers the strongest advantages and determine if any features may need some enhancement for overall functional and aesthetic improvement.

To provide a versatile performance that you can enjoy in different settings, this boot delivers tough durability together with a handsome style.

Ideal For

  • Those who prefer a boot with a premium retro style
  • Working in areas with minimal to zero water exposure
  • People who prefer footwear with a relaxed fit


Performance Analysis


The Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boot offered a remarkably comfortable experience that made my tasks much easier to complete since I didn’t need to suffer from pain throughout the workday and even beyond. The full-grain leather material doesn’t need a long break-in period and can even be fully appreciated straight out of the box, depending on your comfort preference. The upper is sturdy enough to keep up with the demands of various activities but doesn’t have extreme rigidity so it still manages to adapt to my foot’s movements, allowing me to walk and move in the most natural way because I didn’t need to deal with an unyielding material.

I liked how the cushioned insole worked to surround my foot with just the right amount of padding to deliver long hours of comfort without the additional bulk that can make a boot feel extremely tight and heavy.

This insole is covered with the same high-quality leather that was used on the upper, resulting in a footbed that molds to the shape of my foot to bring a customized feel that becomes even more comfortable with each use.

It was such a treat to discover that the boot continues its work to bring a higher level of comfort the more times I use it, instead of breaking down or becoming more uncomfortable as it wears down.

The boot’s interior is fitted with a leather lining that works to allow air to enter freely to maintain a breathable environment so the foot can enjoy lasting freshness and comfort no matter how challenging the day becomes.



The boot tips the scales at a medium weight level and weighs just as much as I expected it to. The premium leather offers reliable durability and rugged appeal but doesn’t come with the extreme thickness that can add a significant level of weight. While it can by no means be considered lightweight, this boot is also not extremely heavy, so I was able to walk and move all throughout the day without bulky footwear weighing my feet down and causing a great deal of discomfort. I believe the steel shank within contributed to the solid feel and weight of the boot that also worked to bring a more stable feeling, which proved to be beneficial when walking on uneven ground.



This boot is equipped with a heavy-duty Vibram mini-lug outsole that is oil-resistant and aims to keep you safe from slipping on various surfaces. However, I found out that the outsole didn’t have the strong traction that I expected to enjoy with what was supposed to be an impressive material. Walking on wet and uneven surfaces was a bit of a challenge, and I didn’t feel secure enough to move confidently or rapidly on these ground conditions, since I felt that I could still have a slipping accident in the process. I would have appreciated the boot even more if the outsole had a firmer grip on the ground so I could have enjoyed the footwear’s benefits for a wider variety of activities and in various settings.


Fit and Sizing

The Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boot offered a relaxed fit that was achieved by going for a smaller-than-my-usual size. I usually go for a size 10, but this time I picked a size 9.5 at the manufacturer’s recommendation. While going down half a size brought a relaxed fit, I believe that going down to a size 9 would still result in a comfortable fit. I liked the bump toe feature that provided more than enough space in the toe box, allowing my toes to shift naturally in place so that preventing cramps from developing was easier to do even with extended hours of boot-wearing. The lace-up design makes it quite easy to adjust the boot when needed to get to a comfortable fit, with the flat laces providing a sturdy and elegant presence that blends remarkably well with the boot’s overall aesthetic.



The boot does not come with waterproof components so it won’t protect your foot from wetness when exposed to water, mud, and other liquid substances.



The leather lining inside is created to permit air to enter the boot to provide proper ventilation so that the foot can remain dry and cool, even with long hours of boot use as you finish numerous tasks. The lining works to disperse excess heat before it can result in discomfort so that you can keep going throughout the day without worrying about overheated feet. This lining also works to dissipate perspiration from within to protect your feet from getting soaked with sweat.


Quality and Durability

The Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boot is built with premium materials that deliver reliable strength without sacrificing comfort and style. The 6-inch height works to protect the foot from dirt and other debris during summertime and just as easily prevents snow from entering the boot in the winter. This tall boot construction works to deliver continuous ankle support so that walking on challenging ground conditions can be managed with confidence and safety throughout the day.

The bump toe structure lends a classic round toe aesthetic that goes well with different clothing choices while providing much-needed space in the top part of the boot so that the toes can wiggle when necessary to avoid foot cramps. The leather-covered insole offers all-day cushioning while molding to the contours of your foot for a customized sensation that keeps getting better the more you use the boot.

The Puritan triple stitching and Goodyear welt on three-quarters of the boot work to deliver dependable durability that enables you to make the most out of the footwear’s superb features for a long time.

The Vibram outsole lends stability and support for your foot as you move continuously, but sadly only offers medium traction so that walking on slippery surfaces can be a challenge to manage.

This boot features a lace-up design with flat laces that add a dignified accent while maintaining a strong profile that can easily take on constant fit adjustment needs. The brass eyelets keep the laces securely in place and are sturdy enough to keep up with the frequent lace movement. A cork midsole works to absorb most of the impact that continuous walking can bring to stop foot fatigue from fully developing while keeping a lightweight profile that doesn’t add significant bulk and weight to the boot.


Other Versions

The Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boot is available in the following options: black prairie leather, briar oil-slick leather, charcoal rough & tough leather, and copper rough & tough leather. All of these options come with the Puritan triple stitching and a three-quarter Goodyear welt for superior durability, as well as the Vibram 430 mini-lug outsole that offers medium traction on various surfaces.


The Challengers

Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Iron Ranger Boot

The Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Iron Ranger Boot offers a more striking aesthetic with a ruggedness that gives a clear idea of the footwear’s lasting strength. This boot looks quite similar to the Blacksmith with its lace-up design that makes constant fit adjustments easy to manage without too much fuss involved. It’s fitted with an all-leather footbed that follows the shape of the foot for a customized fit experience that improves with time, delivering a personalized level of comfort to keep you going through the most challenging activities. The boot is equipped with a reinforced cap toe to strengthen this crucial point so it won’t break down when exposed to abrasive materials in and out of the work area.

Red Wing Heritage Men’s Classic 6-Inch Moc Toe Boot

The Red Wing Heritage Men’s Classic 6-Inch Moc Toe Boot is an excellent choice if you prefer your boot to have a lace-up design with a moc toe structure that offers more space. This style gives the toes the much-needed room to be able to move naturally so that preventing foot cramps can be easier to manage. This boot offers a higher level of protection with its water-repellent leather that can ensure the foot will be kept dry even when water splashes on the boot. It’s built with a flexible crepe outsole that easily adapts to your movements to allow you to work as quickly and as naturally as possible without compromising your comfort in the process. This outsole also delivers superior shock absorption to stop foot fatigue from developing when you have stayed on your feet for the better part of the day and offers continuous support so you can maintain your stability when navigating different floor conditions.

Timberland Larchmont Waterproof Chukka Boot

The Timberland Larchmont Waterproof Chukka Boot is a great choice for working in more extreme environments that require waterproof footwear to guarantee that the foot can enjoy long-lasting dryness. The rubber outsole features deep lugs that are strategically spaced to deliver maximum traction so you can confidently walk on various ground conditions indoors and out while maintaining your safe and confident footing. This outsole is also resistant to abrasions to deliver long-lasting durability that can withstand the challenges of most work settings. The OrthoLite foam insoles are created to provide outstanding cushioning to keep your foot comfortable throughout the day while keeping the boot’s interior properly ventilated and free from harmful bacteria that can cause bad odors.

Danner Workman 6-Inch Boot

The Danner Workman 6-Inch Boot comes with a robust construction that can keep up with different workplace requirements. The full-grain leather upper has passed meticulous testing procedures to guarantee long-lasting strength and resistance to damage that can be caused by water and other liquids. This boot is equipped with a GORE-TEX lining that is 100% waterproof to ensure that liquid substances won’t be able to seep into the boot’s interior, allowing your foot to enjoy all-day dryness amid tough environments. This lining is also breathable, so heat and moisture can easily disperse before they have a chance to build up inside the boot. The sole and heel are created to be non-conductive to provide reliable electrical hazard protection that may be required in certain work settings. The footwear maintains a lightweight structure by combining the midsole, shank, and lasting board in one piece that effortlessly follows the shape of the boot.

Caterpillar Men’s Pelton Steel Toe Work Boot

The Caterpillar Men’s Pelton Steel Toe Work Boot is an awesome alternative if you’re looking for a pull-on boot that can keep you comfortable throughout the day. This boot has a steel toe cap that protects the foot from being seriously injured in the event that tools or heavy objects accidentally fall from a great height within the job site. The EVA midsole works to absorb the shock resulting from the repetitive movements of your steps to protect you from feeling foot pain even with long hours of boot use. The oil- and abrasion-resistant outsole comes with deep treads that deliver strong traction that allows you to move as naturally and as quickly as you need to over tricky surfaces without sacrificing your safety in the process. This boot also offers secondary protection from electrical hazards in dry conditions that you may encounter in and around the workplace.

Conclusion & Verdict

The Red Wing Heritage Men’s 6-Inch Blacksmith Boot showcases a premium retro appeal that looks classy and rugged at the same time. The relaxed fit made the boot a pleasure to wear as it brought all-day comfort and a handsome profile that I was able to fully maximize in different settings. This boot doesn’t have safety toe or waterproof features, though, so they’re not ideal for use in harsh environments where safety hazards and excessive moisture may be encountered.


Luke Davis

Luke is the lead author on He has a vast experience in construction engineering and project management in California and Texas, where he had the chance to put to test a wide range of safety boots and PPE. Outside work, Luke is an avid hiker and not surprisingly a DIY fanatic!