Summary
I found these Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles to be a remarkable find that delivered much more than I hoped from high-quality insoles. I came across these insoles when I was looking for a replacement for the original insoles on my Timberland Pit Boss boots and was so happy when it turned out to be one of the softest and most flexible insoles I’ve ever tried. I loved the multiple layers of massaging gel built into the insole as they greatly impacted overall comfort, especially when I needed to stay on my feet for the better part of the workday. Even if they’re designed for work, these insoles can be fitted into sneakers and casual shoes. The 90-day money-back guarantee was a great bonus as it provided me with the assurance that I have the option to return the insoles in case of any issues after purchase.
Performance Analysis
Comfort
I was searching for new insoles that would make my boots more comfortable, and I was so lucky that my choice – the Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles – stood out exceptionally well in terms of comfort. From the start, it was clear that these were the softest and most flexible insoles I’ve tried. The flexibility made walking so much easier as the insoles followed the feet’s movement and adjusted accordingly – unlike stiff insoles that didn’t feel that comfortable and caused mobility problems as they restricted natural foot motion. In addition, these remarkably soft insoles made my boot’s interior feel considerably better, so it became more comfortable to use for extended periods.
The massaging gel infusion made a huge difference in comfort, elevating these insoles’ ability to prevent foot fatigue and making them much more comfortable than the average insoles with far fewer gel infusions (if any). I love how the gel gave the insoles a bouncy structure that absorbed most of the shock caused by continuous walking for long periods.
The extra gel infusion created a barrier between my feet and the hard surfaces I walked on, saving my feet from the impact of walking and staying upright for extended times. In addition, the bouncy effect propelled my movements, making me feel like I had the extra energy to keep walking for even longer and provide shock absorption.
I was impressed with these insoles’ tough construction as they had an impact not only on durability but also on absorbing the impact. The design helped reduce the development of foot fatigue while offering super cushioning at the same time to keep the cradled in the most gentle, comfortable way. The responsive wave design delivered much-needed padding exactly where required for maximum benefits. The forefoot area even had extra cushioning to protect the ball of the foot against the otherwise painful impact of walking on hard surfaces.
Weight
At 7.25oz, these insoles had a hefty feel as they weighed slightly more than other Dr Scholl insoles. These insoles had a hefty feel as they weighed slightly more than other Dr Scholl insoles. The extra weight gave the insoles a more substantial feel but didn’t add much weight to the boots. Even if these insoles were a bit weightier than other insoles from the same brand, I appreciated that they didn’t make my boots feel too bulky or uncomfortably tight.
Fit and Sizing
I tried these in size 8-14, the only size available for men (they came in an option for size 6-11 for women). However, this wasn’t a problem because I only had to trim them to make them fit perfectly into my size US 10 boots, and I cut the insoles to the desired size using a sharp pair of scissors.
I welcomed how easy it was to trim these insoles to the right size, thanks to the numbers on the toe area at the back, which indicated the precise point where you have to cut for the right fit. This is useful, and only some insole brands offer this feature, which considerably reduces the chances of cutting the insoles to the wrong size.
Breathability
I was happy to discover that these insoles had cooling vents underneath, resolving one less issue I often encounter when using other insoles. The vents allowed the air to pass through to keep the feet cool for longer while making it easier for hot, moist air to escape simultaneously. In addition, these vents helped maintain a cool and dry feeling as I used the insoles for hours, protecting me from the discomfort of having hot, sweaty feet.
Arch Support
These insoles win in softness and flexibility, but I discovered that their flat structures had a downside, too.
They were designed with a flatter profile than other insoles with similar features, resulting in weaker arch support.
This didn’t pose any problems with short periods of boot use, but I felt the difference when I stood and walked for long periods as the insoles didn’t have the strong support to keep foot pain at bay. However, the flatter structure may be advantageous for some who are more comfortable with this insole design, which may also be easier to walk in.
Quality and Durability
The Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles feature a responsive wave design that delivers ample cushioning. These turned out to be one of my favorites regarding the softest and most flexible insoles, helping make my boots much more comfortable and easier to move around. In addition, the remarkable softness and flexibility improved the feel of my boots without compromising mobility in any way, as the insoles allowed my feet to move naturally.
I loved the multiple layers of gel waves that added another dimension of comfortable cushioning for my feet to enjoy. In addition, the massaging gel added a bouncy feel to the insoles, injecting more energy into my steps, so walking and standing for hours didn’t feel too uncomfortable. The gel also worked as a strong shock absorber on the heel and arch areas, taking in and dissipating the impact of continuously stepping on hard surfaces to save the feet from becoming unbearably fatigued.
I’m impressed with the cutting guide included in the toe area of the insoles, making it easier to trim them to the right size while minimizing the risk of mistakes. Even if these insoles only came in one size (8-14 for men; 6-11 for women), they’re quite easy to adjust to the correct size for a completely comfortable and supportive fit.
These insoles came with a 90-day money-back guarantee that spoke of the manufacturer’s full confidence in the quality of their product.
I appreciated this guarantee as it offered an assurance of superior quality and an option to get my money back if I was dissatisfied with my purchase – which wasn’t the case with these insoles. Even with all the impressive features, these insoles were offered at a surprisingly affordable price, providing excellent value for money compared to expensive options that weren’t that effective.
The reinforced construction is supposed to offer strong arch support, but in reality, the almost flat profile of the insoles didn’t deliver the support needed, so these are not suitable for those who require strong arch support. Some people may find the almost flat design more comfortable to wear. These insoles are also a bit heavier than other insole options from the same brand, but the extra weight didn’t affect the overall comfort.
Other Versions
The Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles are offered in an original version featuring a gel infusion that’s less soft and bouncy.
Conclusion & Verdict
I highly recommend the Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles to those who want to make their old boots feel much softer and better to walk on. These insoles are exceptional for people who work long hours on their feet, as the superior cushioning and shock absorption prevents foot fatigue, promoting a comfortable experience that doesn’t go away with prolonged use. The massaging gel adds a bouncy feel that propels the feet and provides shock absorption. The fact that they cost a lot less than other options (which turned out not that effective anyway) adds to these insoles’ fantastic overall value, especially given the remarkable qualities that are much needed by people who spend a lot of time on their feet for work and for other purposes.
- Very soft and flexible
- 90-day money-back guarantee
- Size cutting guide
- Excellent value for money
- Weak arch support
- Slightly heavy