Leather Work Shoes: Worn and Tested Options for Every Job
Leather work shoes are essential in many work outfits, not only in office settings but also in more casual or industrial job environments. Work shoes made with supple leather have distinctively elegant looks and are durable and lightweight too.
With designs with lower profiles than boots, high-quality leather work shoes are often more comfortable to use over long periods.
Typically, these shoes also have other enhancements to meet various workplace demands.
This article presents our top picks for the best leather shoes, carefully selected from a multitude of options that we had the opportunity to wear and thoroughly test in various work scenarios.
We’ve tested and tried numerous leather shoes in different work settings, and we’ve narrowed down the top options.
Our Picks – Best Leather Work Shoes
Best Overall
|
|
Most Comfortable
|
|
Best Safety Toe
|
|
Best Sole
|
|
Most Lightweight
|
Our Picks – Best Leather Work Shoes
- Rating
This is the trial text to check ratings.
- Best in class
- Excellent
- Good
- Fair
- Poor
- Price range
- Overall score
- Performance Breakdown
- Comfort & Fit
- Design & Build Quality
- Durability
- Sole & Traction
- Safety Toe
- Water Resistance
- Value For Money
- Overview
- Pros
- Cons
- Bottom Line
-
-
$169 to $199
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Waterproof
- Odor control system
- Memory foam cushioning
- Shock-absorbing midsole
- Lightweight
-
- No safety toes
- Read Full Review
-
-
$84 to $200
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Memory foam cushioning
- Slip-on design
- Relaxed fit
- Water and stain-resistant
- Lightweight and flexible
-
- No safety toe
- Not fully waterproof
- Read Full Review
-
-
$105 to $200
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Composite toe protection
- Sturdy profile
- Memory foam cushioning
- Electrical hazard protection
- Thick yet flexible sole
-
- Not waterproof
- Heavier than other work shoes
- Read Full Review
-
-
$135 to $199
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- High-traction AirWair sole
- Sole is resistant to oil, alkali, petrol, and fat
- Premium quality leather and construction
- Comfortably flexible after the break-in period
-
- Leather is initially stiff
- Snug fit may be uncomfortable for wide feet
- Read Full Review
-
-
$95 to $200
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Exceptionally lightweight structure
- Breathable lining
- Flexible, slip-resistant outsole
- Generously cushioned, shock-absorbent sole
-
- Unsuitable for wide feet
- Thin laces
- Read Full Review
Table of Contents
Detailed Product Reviews
This is our detailed evaluation of the top leather work shoes that we have worn and tested, based on a detailed methodology, which is discussed further down.
Best Overall
Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe
Material
Waterproof full-grain leatherType of Toe
Soft ToeWeight
2.06lb / 0.94kg / 32.96ozWaterproof
YesShaft Sizes
3 inchesOutsole
Soft Paw II rubber outsoleShoe type
Leather Oxford ShoeManufacturer
Irish SetterSafety certifications
NoPrice range
$169.95 to $199.00- Wearing with jeans and chinos for a more casual look
- Environments that require waterproof shoes with good traction
- Those who prefer a low-cut moc toe design for style and comfort
Price range
$169.95 to $199.00
Pros
- Waterproof
- Odor control system
- Memory foam cushioning
- Shock-absorbing midsole
- Lightweight
Cons
- No safety toes
The Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe delivers excellent performance regarding comfort and protection from the elements.
Its waterproof design maintains comfortable foot dryness that we enjoy even while working in wet areas. In addition, we like the versatile moc-toe design that goes well with workwear and more casual outfits. Memory foam cushioning delivers an almost customized feel inside the shoe, while an EVA midsole absorbs shock to keep us walking pain-free throughout the day.
Despite its full silhouette, the shoe has a lightweight profile that doesn’t feel bulky like other leather work shoes.
Unique Features
Sole
We appreciate the soft Paw II sole’s strong traction as we safely walk over challenging surfaces without losing balance.
What’s even better about this sole is that it’s designed to shed debris continuously, so we didn’t feel the shoe getting heavier with mud and dirt build-up.
It also feels lighter than expected, given its thick and robust structure.
Fit
The snug fit supports the foot’s position and prevents it from sliding uncomfortably with every step.
We like how even with the snug fit, the toe box still has enough room for our toes to wiggle, courtesy of the moc toe design.
We love the memory foam insole and shock-absorbing midsole that work together to make the shoe comfortable even after long hours.
Build
The waterproof leather construction stops water, mud, and other liquids from entering, so our feet don’t get soaked in wet environments.
We’re impressed with the exclusive odor control system that works continuously in the upper and lining materials to fight odor-causing bacteria for a fresh foot feeling that lasts all day.
The moc toe design gives this work shoe versatility that can be enjoyed on and off the workplace.
Summary
The Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe showcases exceptional qualities, including strong waterproofing, an exclusive odor control system, memory foam cushioning, and shock absorption – all within a lightweight, versatile moc toe profile.
Most Comfortable
Skechers Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe
Material
Leather and syntheticType of Toe
Soft ToeWeight
2.56lb / 1.16kg / 40.96ozWaterproof
NoShaft Sizes
3 inchesOutsole
Slip-resistant rubber outsoleShoes type
Slip-onManufacturer
SkechersSafety certifications
NoPrice range
$84.71 to $200.00- Food service professionals and working in other service-related jobs
- Those who prefer lightweight and flexible work shoes
- People who work in settings that require electrical hazard protection
Price range
$84.71 to $200.00
Pros
- Memory foam cushioning
- Slip-on design
- Relaxed fit
- Water and stain-resistant
- Lightweight and flexible
Cons
- No safety toe
- Not fully waterproof
The Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe has features that ensure all-day foot comfort.
The slip-on design offers the convenience of lace-free use, with a relaxed fit that allows the foot to move comfortably inside the shoe.
We love the lightweight design that doesn’t hamper our movements, offering the support that our foot needs without the unwanted bulk. The memory foam insole provides a customized feel while relieving pressure points, so we don’t have to worry about blisters and fatigue interfering with our busy workday. We discovered that the upper is stain and water-resistant for better protection in wet and dirty work environments. This shoe flexes to adapt to our foot’s movements quickly, so nothing is restricting our natural agility in the workplace.
Unique Features
Sole
The slip-resistant outsole delivers a strong grip, making it easy to navigate wet floors and sloped ground while maintaining steady walking.
Walking is made much easier, thanks to the flexible sole that offers reliable support while flexing along with our steps.
Fit
Spending hours on our feet doesn’t feel too challenging because of the memory foam cushioning that protects against discomfort from underneath.
The padded collar supports the ankle and keeps it in place, making it much easier for us to avoid accidental ankle-twisting incidents. In addition, we love the convenience offered by the shoe’s slip-on design, with side gussets that stretch to welcome the foot comfortably.
Build
The water- and the stain-resistant upper is a huge plus when working in wet areas and settings where soiled items – such as food – may cause staining on footwear.
We noted the seams with reinforced stitching and the toe and heel overlays that strengthen the shoe’s structure to deliver superior performance for much longer.
Meanwhile, the electrical hazard-safe design offers a non-primary source of safety against electrocution in dry settings.
Summary
The Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe is an exceptionally comfortable shoe featuring memory foam cushioning, a slip-on, relaxed fit design, a stain and water-resistant upper, with a flexible, lightweight profile.
Best Safety Toe
Skechers Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe
Material
LeatherType of Toe
CompositeWeight
2lb / 0.91kg / 32ozWaterproof
NoShaft Sizes
Relaxed FitOutsole
RubberShoe type
Toe ShoeManufacturer
SkechersSafety certifications
NoPrice range
$105.00 to $200.00- Work areas that are exposed to impact and compression hazards
- Those who prefer a ruggedly casual look for their work shoes
- People who work in areas with slippery or wet floor conditions
Price Range
$105.00 to $200.00
Pros
- Composite toe protection
- Sturdy profile
- Memory foam cushioning
- Electrical hazard protection
- Thick yet flexible sole
Cons
- Not waterproof
- Heavier than other work shoes
The Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe delivers strong toe protection in harsh worksites.
The leather upper gives the shoe a robust design that stands up to heavy use, with composite toe caps to guard our toes against hazardous compression and impact while on the job. We’re fans of the Skechers Memory Foam insole because it cushions the foot for improved comfort even after long hours of standing or walking. The sole feels thick and supportive but is flexible enough to adapt to our steps without compromising comfort.
The shoe’s electrical hazard protection makes it an ideal choice for work areas with risks of contact with electrically charged objects.
Unique Features
Sole
The sole has a rugged structure that gives us a supportive feeling.
It’s thick enough to keep up with challenging ground conditions without easily breaking apart. In addition, this sole has strong traction that helps us avoid slipping accidents on slick or uneven surfaces.
The sole’s sturdiness has a downside, making the shoe considerably heavier than other work shoes.
Fit
We like how the memory foam layer on the sole followed the foot’s curves for a personalized fit, with a soft fabric to help prevent chafing with continuous foot movements.
The padded collar offers welcome cushioning that also helps promote a snug fit, keeping our ankle in place so it won’t easily twist. In addition, the flexible upper and sole makes walking more comfortable since no stiff materials are digging into the foot.
Build
The shoe’s robust structure holds up strongly throughout the most demanding tasks, so we’re assured that we’ll maximize its use for a long time.
The composite toe caps protect the toes from being crushed by heavy items that can accidentally roll or drop on the feet. In addition, an electrical hazard-safe design offers a secondary level of safety in case of sudden contact with open circuits.
Summary
The Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe delivers superior protection in the workplace with its composite toe caps and electrical hazard protection, along with other notable features such as memory foam cushioning, a sturdy yet flexible profile, and a thick outsole.
Best Sole
Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe
Material
LeatherType of Toe
Soft ToeWeight
2.38lb / 1.08kg / 38.08ozWaterproof
NoShaft Sizes
3 inchesOutsole
AirWair soleShoe type
Leather Oxford ShoeManufacturer
Dr. MartensSafety certifications
NoPrice range
$135.99 to $199.00- All types of indoor jobs
- Outdoor jobs in non-hazardous environments
- Those who prefer durable shoes with a classic style and snug fit
Price range
$135.99 to $199.00
Pros
- High-traction AirWair sole
- Sole is resistant to oil, alkali, petrol, and fat
- Premium quality leather and construction
- Comfortably flexible after the break-in period
Cons
- Leather is initially stiff
- Snug fit may be uncomfortable for wide feet
The Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe’s timeless profile always impresses, but its appearance isn’t the only aspect that makes this a noteworthy leather work shoe. We’re amazed at the sole outstanding construction because it strongly grips most surfaces and is resistant to oil, fuel, alkali, and fat. In addition, the premium build showcases high-quality leather – available in several color variations – that lasts a long time, even with heavy use in difficult conditions.
Unique Features
Sole
The distinctively translucent appearance of the Dr Martens AirWair sole gives this sole a striking look while also delivering superb functionality. We love how grippy the sole feels, helping us walk much more steadily across slippery or uneven ground conditions. In addition, the sole is remarkably tough and has a strong resistance to oil, alkali, fat, and fuel. This resistant quality assures us of lasting performance even when the boot is used in environments where these harsh substances are present.
Fit
When using these boots, our feet feel comfortably locked in place, so walking on varying surfaces is easier without feeling unsteady. Once the leather upper is fully broken, these boots conform to our feet and deliver an almost customized comfort level. In addition, we’re fans of the strong yet flexible sole that instantly follows our feet’s motion for maximum mobility. We don’t recommend these boots for wide feet, though, as the snug fit may feel uncomfortable, especially after hours of continuous use.
Build
The robust leather upper is showcased in a timeless silhouette, which we can enjoy at work and in more laidback surroundings. The premium leather is initially unyielding but eventually softens to follow the feet’s shape. We appreciate the classic Dr Martens look enhanced by the distinguishing yellow stitching between the upper and sole. In addition, the Goodyear welt construction offers superior durability that we can maximize for long-term use.
Summary
The Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe outshines other options with its superior sole design & build. It also has other notable qualities, including premium-quality leather that offers a customized fit after the break-in period, sturdy metallic and sturdy metallic hardware, and reliable Goodyear welt construction.
Most Lightweight
Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe
Material
Leather and syntheticType of Toe
Soft ToeWeight
1.95lb / 0.86kg / 31.2ozWaterproof
NoShaft Sizes
3 inchesOutsole
Rubber outsoleShoe type
Cushion ShoeManufacturer
ReebokSafety certifications
NoPrice range
$95.00 to $200.00- Jobs that involve long hours of walking or standing
- Those who are after flexible, lightweight work shoes with a sporty look
- Indoor and outdoor (non-hazardous) work environments
Price range
$95.00 to $200.00
Pros
- Exceptionally lightweight structure
- Breathable lining
- Flexible, slip-resistant outsole
- Generously cushioned, shock-absorbent sole
Cons
- Unsuitable for wide feet
- Thin laces
The Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe has a superbly lightweight design that makes walking more enjoyable, even after prolonged shoe use.
We like its flexible structure that doesn’t hinder our natural agility in the workplace. The slip-resistant outsole offers good traction and isn’t as bulky as thicker soles. We appreciate the mesh lining that helps maintain a breathable interior even after long shoe use in hot surroundings.
Meanwhile, generous cushioning technology – similar to that used in basketball shoes – delivers comforting softness and reliable shock absorption right where they’re needed.
Unique Features
Sole
The slip and oil-resistant outsole has a good grip on most surfaces, but more than the traction level will be needed for extremely slippery ground conditions. We appreciate the sole’s flexibility because it helps us walk comfortably since there’s no stiffness to hamper our natural foot movements.
However, the sole is less robust than those with thicker structures.
Fit
Ample cushioning on the sole also works on impact absorption, with an air-cushioned structure that gives the shoe an almost weightless feel.
The lightly padded collar and tongue help maintain a secure fit and prevent the foot from shifting unintentionally with every step. However, the shoe leans toward the snug side, so we don’t recommend it for wide feet.
Build
We’re fans of the leather upper as it gives the shoe a professional look suitable for work settings, with a slightly sporty vibe for versatility. The mesh lining thankfully lets our feet breathe even in warm conditions. In addition, reinforced heel and toe areas strengthen the shoe to help resist premature damage.
We’re concerned that the thin laces aren’t as strong as thicker options and won’t last as long, especially with heavy shoe use.
Summary
The Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe has a remarkably lightweight design. In addition, it boasts notable qualities such as supportive cushioning and shock absorption, flexible sole, breathable lining, and a professional but still slightly sporty vibe.
Comparison Table
Product | Upper | Weight Level | Safety Toe |
---|---|---|---|
Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe | Waterproof full-grain leather | Lightweight | None (soft toe) |
Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe | Smooth-oiled suede leather and textile | Medium | Composite toe |
Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe | Leather and textile | Lightweight | None (soft toe) |
Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe | Full-grain leather | Medium | None (soft toe) |
Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe | Leather and textile | Lightweight | None (soft toe) |
Selection Methodology
Our team chose the products in this list based on the qualities we decided were most crucial in the best leather work shoes.
High-Quality Leather Uppers – the uppers of the best leather work shoes are made with high quality materials that deliver superior aesthetics. They also perform well in various work environments while protecting their feet daily.
Minimized Weight – the best leather work shoes typically have reduced weight profiles that don’t pull the feet down with too much bulk. These low-key silhouettes make walking around the work area easier without carrying weighty footwear.
Comfortable Cushioning – leather work shoes with ample padding work better as they’re more comfortable to wear. With the right level of cushioning on the sole, collar, and tongue, leather work shoes won’t cause pain even with long hours of use.
Durability – top-quality leather work shoes have strong materials and designs to cope better with various work requirements and activities. These work shoes can be relied on to perform well and provide long-lasting benefits.
Product Performance Evaluation & Ratings
After evaluating them based on the most crucial categories for the best leather work shoes, we selected the products in this list. The comfort & fit category looks at the level of comfort that the work shoe can offer. The design & build quality category touches on the aspects that affect performance and aesthetics. The durability category examines the structures’ ability to keep up with different work conditions and activities while maintaining a sturdy profile. The safety toe category establishes the presence of safety toe caps as protection against heavy rolling or falling objects. The sole & traction category inspects the outsole structure and the level of grip that it delivers. The water resistance category confirms the presence of waterproof or water-resistant materials to keep wetness out. Lastly, the value-for-money category studies the relationship between the product’s price and overall quality.
Overall
The Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe gets the highest score in this list, showcasing outstanding features, including a waterproof upper with a stylish moc-toe silhouette, memory foam cushioning, and an exclusive odor control system – with a rating of 8.7.
The Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe comes next with superb attributes, including the convenience of a slip-on design, memory foam insole, and a stain- and water-resistant upper, getting a rating of 8.3.
The Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe is next with exceptional qualities such as composite toe protection, sturdy profile, and shock-absorbing midsole, with a rating of 8. Finally, the same rating is given to the Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe for its remarkable qualities, such as a high-traction sole resistant to oil, fuel, and alkali, tough construction, and customized comfort.
The Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe comes in last but still has noteworthy characteristics, including an exceptionally lightweight structure, a breathable lining, and shock absorption, with a rating of 7.5.
Comfort & Fit
The Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe and Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe get top marks for exceptionally comfortable features such as memory foam cushioning and lightweight, flexible structures, with a rating of 9.
The Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe has a slightly lower score because it can feel too snug but still offers superb comfort with an exceptionally lightweight design and ample cushioning – getting a rating of 8.
The Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe has the lowest score because its structure is a bit heavier than other work shoes, tied with the Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe that feels almost unbearably stiff when it’s not yet broken in – with both getting the same rating of 7.
Design & Build Quality
The Dr. Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe lands on top for design & build quality, featuring remarkably strong traction and a sole with reliable resistance to several harsh liquids, robust metallic hardware, and a sturdy yet premium-looking leather upper – earning a rating of 9.
The other four products all have the same slightly lower scores but still deliver superior attributes for performance and aesthetics, such as reliable shock absorption, memory foam cushioning, and electrical hazard protection – with the same rating of 8.
Durability
The Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe, Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe, and Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe get the highest marks for their robust profiles offering long-lasting benefits – all getting a rating of 9.
The Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe comes in next with water- and stain-resistant upper and reinforced sections, earning a rating of 8.
The Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe comes in last with a structure negatively affected by thin laces – getting a rating of 7.
Sole & Traction
The Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe, Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe, Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe, and Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe all get the same high scores for strong traction, with a rating of 8.
The Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe gets in last because even if the outsole is slip-resistant, it’s thinner than other outsoles and doesn’t have an exceptional grip, getting a rating of 7.
Safety Toe
The Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe is the only one rated for this category because of its composite toe protection, rated 9. The other four products don’t have safety toe enhancements.
Water Resistance
The Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe has the highest score for its waterproof design, with a rating of 9.
The Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe gets second place with its water-resistant structure, rating 8.
The other three products have the same significantly lower scores because they don’t offer any liquid resistance, with a rating of 6.
Value for Money
The Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe, Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe, Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe, Dr Martens 1461 Leather Oxford Shoe, and Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe all offered excellent value for money, with the same rating of 9.
Conclusion
Wearing the proper footwear can make work-related tasks much easier to deal with. The best leather work shoes are sturdy enough to meet the demands of different job sites but need the bulkiness of work boots. The top 3 products we evaluated – the Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe, Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe, and Skechers Work Flex Advantage Bronwood Shoe – all have robust yet comfortable profiles, promoting pain-free use even over long periods of walking or staying upright. These work shoes are made with high-quality leather that exhibits a professional aesthetic while showcasing almost sporty silhouettes for maximum versatility.
FAQs
- Do leather work shoes look good only with formal office wear?
- No, some leather work shoes – such as the Reebok Work and Cushion 4.0 Shoe – have sporty designs suitable for casual work attire.
- Are all leather work shoes suitable only for indoor work?
- No, there are leather work shoes – especially the waterproof ones like the Irish Setter Soft Paw Waterproof Leather Shoe – that can be used for outdoor tasks and even in wet conditions.
- Can leather work shoes be used in hazardous job sites?
- Yes, provided they have the necessary safety features. Leather work shoes are suitable for hazardous work sites only if they have safety enhancements such as safety toe caps, electrical hazard protection, or puncture resistance.
- Are all leather work shoes lightweight?
- No. Some, like the Skechers Work Soft Stride Grinnell Comp Toe Shoe, can be slightly heavier than others because of their materials and designs.