Dr. Scholl’s Heavy Duty Support Insoles considerably improved the comfort of our boots and made them more enjoyable to use. With a weight of 6.2 oz, these are some of the lightest insoles we’ve tried. We loved how these insoles provided ample support and cushioning without the unpleasant heaviness that would’ve dragged on our feet. Even with the lightweight profile, the insoles still felt sturdy and tough enough to last for a long time. The insoles came in one size option for men and one for women, but we didn’t have a hard time making them fit our boots because they had size indicators that guided where the material needed to be cut. We’re impressed with the deep heel cup enhanced with a gel-like material that worked as a strong shock absorber while securing the heel in place. We would’ve liked these insoles even more if they had stronger arch support and more cushioning on the ball of the foot area.

Unique Features  

Cushioning

We liked how these insoles are designed to deliver cushioning throughout the entire length, not just on certain portions. The cushioning made the insoles comfortably soft but didn’t add much weight to the boots we used for work. We also appreciated the gel-like cushioning on the heel cup, providing strong shock absorption to prevent discomfort.

Arch Support

The arch area featured an orange-colored enhancement that introduced a bit of rigidity, making this component stand out against the softness of the rest of the insoles’ structure. The rigidity provided good arch support, although we didn’t feel it was strong enough to prevent discomfort with heavy use.

Fit & Build

These insoles came in one size option for men (8-14) and women (6-11). Thankfully, we had an easy time customizing the insoles to the right size because they came with numbers at the back, indicating the precise areas where the material should be cut to get the correct shoe size. We liked the sturdy construction that felt robust enough to last through extensive use while resisting damage, with a 90-day money-back guarantee to back up the product’s quality. We’re just as impressed with these insoles’ lightweight structure contributing to the overall comfort level.

Summary

Dr. Scholl’s Heavy Duty Support Insoles are our best overall choice because of remarkable qualities such as strong shock absorption, good arch support, a 90-day money-back guarantee, durable construction, and a lightweight profile.

When we first saw the Powerstep Pinnacle Insoles, we knew they’d deliver strong arch support. These are serious contenders for the top spot regarding insoles offering exceptional arch support. The pronounced curve is designed to cradle the arches, effectively stopping them from dropping, so we were able to walk for hours without discomfort in this area. We loved how these insoles significantly improved the feel of our work boots and made them much more comfortable. The antimicrobial top cover was a wonderful bonus as it inhibited bacterial growth, making it easier for us to avoid smelly feet problems even with long hours of continuous boot use. We’ve pleasantly surprised that these insoles were offered in exact sizes, as we didn’t have to trim them first to make them fit correctly into our work boots.

Unique Features  

Cushioning

We loved that these insoles didn’t skimp on cushioning even as they focused on providing strong arch support. The top layer felt soft and comfy, amping up the comfortable feeling as the softness eased the discomfort of walking and standing for extended periods. We would’ve loved these insoles even more if they offered thicker cushioning in the heel area for increased shock absorption.

Arch Support

These insoles stand out the most in the arch support department. We’re impressed with the structure’s defined curve as it strongly supported the arches, preventing them from falling, which would’ve resulted in a great deal of discomfort. A thicker, more rigid bottom layer also helped enhance arch support for all-day comfort.

Fit & Build

The insoles have a robust design featuring two layers – a softly cushioned top layer and a thicker one for added support. We believe the durable structure will last for a long time. We loved that these insoles were available in exact sizes, eliminating the need for trimming as we already had the right size that would fit effortlessly into our boots from the start. In addition, they’re enhanced with an antimicrobial treatment, greatly reducing the risk that odor issues will develop after long hours of use.

Summary

The Powerstep Pinnacle Insoles stand out with outstandingly strong arch support, but it’s also a winner regarding soft, comfortable cushioning. They also showcase antimicrobial enhancement for odor control and are available in exact sizes.

Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles stood out with their exceptional softness, making our work boots considerably more comfortable than when they still had the original insoles. We loved that a big portion of the structures was enhanced with a gel material, making these the softest and most flexible insoles we’ve tried. The material delivered superb cushioning and shock absorption, stopping discomfort from setting in even after we’ve walked for hours. We appreciated the size guide at the back made it a lot easier to achieve the correct size as it guided us to the exact points where the material needed to be cut. These insoles were slightly heavier than other options from the same brand, although that didn’t result in the structure becoming uncomfortably heavy inside the work boots. They surprisingly came at an affordable price point, offering excellent value for money compared to insoles with less impressive features offered at more than twice the price.

Unique Features  

Cushioning

We loved the generously cushioned feel of these insoles as they made our work boots much more comfortable to use, even for long periods. The gel component worked to massage our feet while protecting them against the crushing impact of walking in hard ground conditions. We appreciated how this material continuously absorbed the shock and dissipated it to prevent foot fatigue.

Arch Support

These insoles were made with rigid side panels to keep the arch support. However, these enhancements didn’t work as well as planned because the rest of the insoles had a much flatter design compared to other insoles, resulting in the feet not getting the arch support they needed.

Fit & Build

Available in one size for men (8-14) and women (6-11), these insoles were quite easy to modify to the correct right size, thanks to the sizing guides incorporated into the back. By simply trimming along the appropriate size mark, we could get the right size that easily fits into our work boots. We liked that these insoles felt solid and well made, with the 90-day money-back guarantee offering additional assurance of the product’s exceptional quality. They’re a bit heavier than other Dr Scholl’s insoles, but the extra weight didn’t result in discomfort.

Summary

Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles was the clear winner regarding softness, thanks to the gel material that made them the softest and most flexible insoles we’ve tried. They also offered strong shock absorption and size indicators for hassle-free cutting to get the correct shoe size.

Dr. Scholl’s Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Insoles are hard to beat when providing pain relief, especially for those suffering from plantar fasciitis. They came with an impressive balance of support and softness, with enough rigidity to stabilize footing without compromising comfort. In addition, they’re not as flat as other insoles and offer strong arch support to prevent discomfort in this area. We appreciated how these insoles supported the arches but still felt comfortably soft, thanks to the considerably softer material used to reinforce support. The ergonomic design followed the foot’s shape for all-day comfort, and we liked that the structure has just the right level of thickness to fit easily into the footwear. Meanwhile, the heel pad worked as a reliable shock absorber and softened every heel strike to minimize the risk of foot fatigue.

Unique Features  

Cushioning

We liked these insoles’ nicely cushioned structure, particularly in the arch. We were a bit surprised since most insoles had rigid arch support that can become uncomfortable – but this wasn’t the case with these insoles. Instead, the structure supporting the arch was cushiony, so the insoles felt pleasantly soft throughout their lengths. We also appreciated the cushioned heel pad, as it absorbed most of the shock produced by walking on hard floors.

Arch Support

These insoles were built specifically to relieve pain by supporting the arches, keeping them stabilized to protect them from dropping after hours of staying upright. The cushioning, keeping the support reinforcement soft and welcoming, made the arch support for these insoles even better – although we won’t recommend this for those who prefer more rigid support.

Fit & Build

The insoles are available in one size – 8-13 for men and 6-10 for women – but we easily trimmed them to the correct size with the help of size indicators placed at the back. They’re ergonomically designed and aren’t as flat as other insoles, so they’re more comfortable to wear for extended periods. In addition, these insoles are durable and quite well made, and we expect them to last a long time.

Summary

Dr. Scholl’s Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Insoles are an excellent choice for those suffering from plantar fasciitis. They’re also suitable for those who want comfortable insoles that aren’t too soft or too rigid, with features such as cushiony soft arch support, ergonomic design, and a shock-absorbing heel pad.

EasyFeet Insoles offer strong foot fatigue prevention that helps us walk comfortably for longer periods. We liked the structure’s defined curve that helped stabilize the foot arch, supporting it in its proper position to prevent extreme discomfort after walking or standing on hard surfaces all day. We appreciated the addition of a gel-like material in the heel and forefoot areas, helping these sections to absorb shock more efficiently, so it’s easier to avoid foot fatigue throughout long hours of staying on our feet. Available in size options that cover two shoe sizes, the insoles may need to be trimmed a bit to get a perfect size. Even if they’re not the softest option out there, these insoles still managed to provide comfortable cushioning, although we won’t recommend them to those who want to make their boots or shoes a lot softer.

Unique Features  

Cushioning

The top layer of these insoles is cushioned nicely and offers a soothing texture, even if it’s not as soft as the ones used in other insoles. In addition, we loved the infusion of a gel-like material in the forefoot and heel pad sections, promoting enhanced shock absorption while adding a bouncy effect that boosted our energy to walk for much longer periods. However, these insoles are not the best option for those who want to make their shoes or boots considerably softer.

Arch Support

We liked the insoles’ defined shape that delivered exceptional arch support, protecting the arches, so they didn’t easily become uncomfortable after standing or walking for a long time. The thick bottom layer reinforced the supportive nature of these insoles but had the downside of making the insoles the least flexible ones we’ve tried so far.

Fit & Build

These insoles are offered in sizes like clothing – XS, S, M, L, XL – each covering two shoe sizes. As these aren’t exact sizes, some trimming is most likely needed to get the perfect sizing. However, these are quite well-made and offer long-lasting performance, with the two layers offering a balance of cushioning and support.

Summary

The EasyFeet Insoles are ideal for preventing foot fatigue, with a defined shape reinforcing the exceptional arch support even with all-day use. Shock-absorbing pads on the forefoot and heel areas soften the impact of continuous steps, while a soft top layer offers a soothing texture.